Do email open rates matter?

When I first got into email marketing, I was obsessed with open rates.

I would send an email and then wait breathlessly while the stats started to roll in.

I asked other email marketers what their open rates were to see how I stacked up.

If I wrote a good subject line and my opens spiked, I did a little fist pump and felt good about myself for 2 days.

And when my subject line tanked, I sulked.

Over time, though, I gradually stopped paying attention.

Here’s why:

The more emails I sent, the more I noticed that my open rates would vary a LOT depending on different factors.

The subject line was the biggie, of course. A really amazing subject line could easily bump my open rates by 5-10% or more.

But there are literally dozens of other factors, including:

  • How the list was built

  • How frequently you email the list

  • The industry or niche the list represents

  • The time of day, the day of the week, the season of the year

  • How many emails get flagged as spam by Gmail and Yahoo!

Many of those factors are beyond my control, so obsessing about opens just leads to frustration.

But there’s an even bigger reason that I largely ignore my open rates now:

Open rates often have ZERO bearing on sales.

Now people DO have to open the emails before they can buy. That much is true.

But all an open means is that you’ve grabbed someone’s attention.

Here’s the key:

All attention is NOT created equally.

It matters WHOSE attention you grab.

If you flag down the wrong part of your audience, it can actually hurt your sales.

In my next email I have a little case study to share.

I’m calling it “the little email that could,” and it illustrates what I’m talking about here perfectly.

Until then…

I’m still finalizing the details of my coaching program.

But I can tell you this much:

After we work together, you won’t be stressing about “vanity metrics” like this.

Instead you’ll know how to write compelling, story-based emails that make SALES.

To make sure you’re in the loop for my announcement, contact me here:

http://joshuaearl.com/contact

Related posts:

  1. How to Skyrocket Your Email Open Rates with the ‘Uncle Sam Formula’ A few weeks back a client emailed me to say how he could hardly believe the open rate on one of the emails I’d written for him. This client has a list that’s normally very active and engaged. But the subject line I wrote for this particular email set his...
  2. When Conversion Rates Lie Conversion rates are nasty, lying little devils. Especially the way many marketers talk about them. Case in point: A few days ago I was reading a post on Inbound.org about the growing popularity of “welcome gate” style optin forms. More and more sites are using tools like SumoMe and Thrive...
  3. Why I Never Use ‘Pretty’ HTML Templates In Email Marketing “Uh, are you sure about this? This isn’t the kind of email we usually send out. I’m not sure how this is going to work…” The response made me chuckle—exactly what I’d expected. “Heh heh, trust me,” I thought, “this is gonna work juuuust fine.” The reluctant guy I was...
  4. How often should I email my list? (case study) One of the biggest “controversies” in email marketing is this: How often should I mail my list? The gurus are all over the map on this. On one hand, you have guys like Matt Furey and Ben Settle who take an aggressive approach—emailing every day, sometimes even multiple times per...